Burning Ropes: Timing the Irregular
This classic logic puzzle challenges you to measure exactly 45 minutes using just:
- 2 ropes, each taking exactly 1 hour to burn end-to-end,
- A lighter, and
- The knowledge that the ropes burn non-linearly (i.e., not at a consistent rate).
Constraints
- You cannot fold or cut the ropes.
- You cannot assume uniform burning.
- But you can light either or both ends of either rope at any time.
The Strategy
Here’s the clever trick: leverage the doubling of burn rate when lighting both ends.
Step-by-Step Solution
-
Light Rope A at both ends and Rope B at one end simultaneously.
- Rope A will burn twice as fast and take exactly 30 minutes to be consumed.
-
As soon as Rope A finishes burning (after 30 minutes), immediately light the other end of Rope B.
- At this point, Rope B has burned for 30 minutes from one end, so half remains—but again, due to irregular burn rate, we don’t know where the flame is.
- Lighting the other end now causes it to burn from both ends, which doubles the burn rate of the remaining segment.
-
The remaining rope will now take 15 minutes to finish burning.
- 30 minutes + 15 minutes = 45 minutes in total.
Why It Works
Even though the burn rate is inconsistent, lighting both ends guarantees a known time: the rope burns completely in half the original time regardless of rate variability. That’s the core trick.
Final Answer
Light Rope A at both ends and Rope B at one end. When Rope A finishes (30 min), light the other end of Rope B. When Rope B finishes, 45 minutes have passed.